A Quick Note to white Republicans

For every white Republican who wants to claim their “grand” old party abolished slavery, championed Abraham Lincoln, supported Civil Rights legislation, and had MLK Jr. within its ranks: none of this absolves fellow white Republicans of the crazy racist shit they pull in the present day.

First of all, something that existed 200 years ago is not going to be exactly the same in the contemporary moment. What Republicans did in the past doesn’t change what Republicans are doing now. The same goes for the Democratic party, which I don’t give a shit about defending. Having a debate about Republicans and Democrats that long ago is essentially a debate about which group of powerful white men compared and contrasted to another group of powerful white men. The nature of this debate has changed very little. Despite having a Black president, it’s still a matter of white majority party versus white majority party in the US. So even if the subject is The Civil Rights Act of 1964, it isn’t much of an impressive or mind-altering knowledge drop considering one white majority party mostly voted for it and the other white majority party mostly voted against it. “These apples once had a slightly nicer taste than these other apples” isn’t much of an argument.

Then there’s Honest Abe with his Emancipation Proclamation. A well-intentioned executive order, I’ll give you that, but claiming it abolished slavery is… a gross exaggeration and a horrendously inaccurate overstatement. Freeing some slaves from chattel slavery =/= abolishing chattel slavery. Emancipation was more of a political solution to secessionist violence in the South (see the Civil War), and it took a considerable amount of time for any freeing of slaves to actually occur. It was issued as a “necessary war measure,” not a social justice document. The Supreme Court had already passed the Dred Scott decision in 1857, which made it impossible for slaves to become citizens on the basis of them being less than human and voided the Missouri Compromise as “unconstitutional,” making slavery legal in all US territories. Only the Supreme Court (white male majority for centuries) had the power to legally abolish slavery.

The fact that you have to remind people that MLK Jr. was a Republican speaks volumes about how important his political affiliation was and is to the party itself. Republican politicians and pundits in the US rarely, if ever, speak with pride about Dr. King as a party member and/or use his image to promote their platforms and policies. Glenn Beck appropriated the anniversary of The Dream speech to have a “white civil rights” Tea Party rally, meaning this doesn’t count. Not to mention, throwing Dr. King’s image in the faces of Obama voters isn’t even remotely showing pride in his affiliation to the party either. Exploiting one Republican, whose history and life’s work were so much more than just being a Republican, does not change the party as a whole.

—DD

Advertisements
Tagged , , , ,

2 thoughts on “A Quick Note to white Republicans

  1. G says:

    Why does it matter if we’re white Republicans, or black Republicans, or any other demographic of Republicans?

    The Dred Scott decision is one small part of the impetus that got Abraham Lincoln elected. The Emancipation Proclamation was political, but it was the post-war 13th Amendment in 1865 that abolished slavery. Passed with 100% Republican support against nearly unanimous Democratic opposition.

    The reason why the history of the Republican Party, slavery, and race is important today is most people are ignorant of these basic facts. Celebrating MLK’s vision of judging people as individuals is not exploitation, it is a continuation of the founding and enduring principles of what our country is supposed to stand for. Educating Americans on these historical facts should be championed, then we can allow each individual to decide whether they are relevant or not.

    • The problem I have with attempting to “teach” people this history of the Republican party is that every time I’ve seen this happen it has been a white Republican trying to prove the Republican party isn’t racist. Also, it involves the dismissal of racist Republicans in the present moment, as if their actions have no meaning because this history of the party somehow protects them. This isn’t a civil service, it is intellectually dishonest and motivated by questionable/political ulterior motives.

      And actually, no, Dred Scott was not a decision that got Abraham Lincoln elected. And, no, the Emancipation Proclamation DID NOT and COULD NOT abolish slavery, because the Dred Scott decision made slavery LEGAL in all states. Only the Supreme Court had the power to abolish slavery. The Proclamation was only drafted to free SOME slaves, and mostly those in northern states.

      In no way did Dr. King’s teachings or life work uphold the “founding values” or “principles” of the constitution. Herein lies another problem with the desire to “teach” this kind of history: it usually involves, again, white folks who are ignorant of actual history themselves. The constitution was written by colonizing, slave-owning, white men at the intentional exclusion of POC and women. American Individualism–an extension of Capitalism–was not something Dr. King taught. He was fighting for a community and justice for all, not the individual. He was fighting against social/legal injustice, oppression, and racism–something this country has always stood for and practiced.

      Why does race matter? Why can’t we all just be “human beings”? Because society and systems of power, domestically and abroad, do not treat people this way and do not reflect this type of thinking. Until that happens, race and any other identity will always matter.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: